With all of the drama and confusion that has occurred in Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night, it is difficult to predict if there will be happy ending or not. Conflicts in the plot have heightened and there is a clear difference between appearances and actuality. Now that Olivia has decided to marry Sebastian because she thinks he is Cesario, she is going to be unhappy when she realizes who she is truly married to. This would limit a happy ending for Sebastian because although he questions if Olivia is crazy, he says "I'll follow this good man and go with you. And, having sworn truth, ever will be true" (I.V. iii. 33-34) in regards to Olivia's marriage proposal. Thus, despite either outcome, one of them is bound to get hurt.
With the marriage of Sebastian and Olivia, various other characters will face heartbreak- resulting in an unhappy ending for them. Duke Orsino, Sir Andrew, and Malvolio, all men who like Olivia, will be upset to see she has chosen another man. Antonio will also be unhappy to see his friend and possible lover, Sebastian, getting married. Unless the marriage falls through, many character's heartbreak will result in an unhappy ending.
However, if the marriage follows through, Viola may have a chance at a happy ending with Duke Orsino. Because her brother would be married, she may feel comfortable exposing herself as a woman rather than Cesario. Duke Orsino may be interested in Viola, and thus create at least one happy ending in the play that is Twelfth Night.
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
Friday, November 14, 2014
Shakespeare & Gender Roles
In Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night, he uses the characterization of gender roles to portray the message that women are as capable of loving as men are. Throughout Twelfth Night, Orsino continually degrades women's ability to be lovers. In Act 2 scene 4, Orsino says "There is no woman's sides can bide the beating of so strong a passion, as love doth give my heart; no woman's heart so big, to hold so much; they lack retention" (II.iv.103-106). Orsino is implying that women cannot love as deeply and passionately as men. Shakespeare refutes this point through the characterization of Viola- a young woman who loves Orsino just as greatly as Orsino loves Olivia. Viola, dressed as Cesario, says "Too well what love women to men may owe: in faith, they are as true of the heart as we" (II.iv. 116-117). This contrast between Orsino's views on women and Viola's views enable the reader to see that women are just as intelligent, strong, and emotionally capable as men.
I feel as though this message is still incredibly prevalent today. Even now, women are portrayed as the weaker, more vulnerable gender. In the video "10 Chick Flick Chichés You Won't See in He's Just Not That Into You" the stereotypes women face are explored. In movies, the female character is usually superficial, naive, and overcome with love. This inaccurate portrayal of women presents them as weak, and unequal to men. Before true equality can be reached, the unjust gender roles presented by the media need to be eliminated.
In my own life there have been instances where I have been discriminated against due to gender. Often times at Model UN, male delegates will ignore the female ones, thinking their unprepared or less smart. This is a major problem because without the acknowledgement of women, no problem will ever be solved cohesively.
Shakespeare's message was one of gender equality, and centuries later this is something we still lack. In order to achieve true gender equality, the stereotypes of gender roles must be ignored.
I feel as though this message is still incredibly prevalent today. Even now, women are portrayed as the weaker, more vulnerable gender. In the video "10 Chick Flick Chichés You Won't See in He's Just Not That Into You" the stereotypes women face are explored. In movies, the female character is usually superficial, naive, and overcome with love. This inaccurate portrayal of women presents them as weak, and unequal to men. Before true equality can be reached, the unjust gender roles presented by the media need to be eliminated.
In my own life there have been instances where I have been discriminated against due to gender. Often times at Model UN, male delegates will ignore the female ones, thinking their unprepared or less smart. This is a major problem because without the acknowledgement of women, no problem will ever be solved cohesively.
Shakespeare's message was one of gender equality, and centuries later this is something we still lack. In order to achieve true gender equality, the stereotypes of gender roles must be ignored.
Monday, November 3, 2014
SPOTTTS Analysis "Diving into the Wreck"
Subject- discovering oneself amidst societal expectations
Paraphrase- Stanza 1: The narrator is putting on equipment and is preparing for a dive into the wreck. They are alone, without the help of others.
Stanza 2: There is a ladder on the boat which allows people to descend into the ocean, offering hope for a new start. But to those who do not take the opportunity, it remains a ladder.
Stanza 3: The diver climbs down the ladder, and enters the ocean alone. She questions how she will survive with no one to tell her where the ocean begins.
Stanza 4: She swims deeper, and wonders how much of an impact she makes on the large ocean.
Stanza 5: Once the diver is deep into the ocean, she realizes her purpose is not clear.
Stanza 6: The diver discovers the shipwreck and looks for her purpose there.
Stanza 7: The diver views herself as a part of the shipwreck, and wants to find her own purpose rather than what others say about her.
Stanza 8: The diver still feels alone, despite new found independence
Stanza 9: The diver looks for hidden treasure that no one else has found deeper in the water. She feels like she is know more broken and alone.
Stanza 10: It is a human experience to be lost, and is necessary to find oneself.
Occasion: Diving into the water and finding oneself as a different person
Tone: reflective, and lonely
Title: About conquering fears and looking beyond societal expectations
Speaker: The diver who is finding herself.
Paraphrase- Stanza 1: The narrator is putting on equipment and is preparing for a dive into the wreck. They are alone, without the help of others.
Stanza 2: There is a ladder on the boat which allows people to descend into the ocean, offering hope for a new start. But to those who do not take the opportunity, it remains a ladder.
Stanza 3: The diver climbs down the ladder, and enters the ocean alone. She questions how she will survive with no one to tell her where the ocean begins.
Stanza 4: She swims deeper, and wonders how much of an impact she makes on the large ocean.
Stanza 5: Once the diver is deep into the ocean, she realizes her purpose is not clear.
Stanza 6: The diver discovers the shipwreck and looks for her purpose there.
Stanza 7: The diver views herself as a part of the shipwreck, and wants to find her own purpose rather than what others say about her.
Stanza 8: The diver still feels alone, despite new found independence
Stanza 9: The diver looks for hidden treasure that no one else has found deeper in the water. She feels like she is know more broken and alone.
Stanza 10: It is a human experience to be lost, and is necessary to find oneself.
Occasion: Diving into the water and finding oneself as a different person
Tone: reflective, and lonely
Title: About conquering fears and looking beyond societal expectations
Speaker: The diver who is finding herself.
Monday, October 27, 2014
"The Awakening" Critizisms
In George M. Spangler’s essay
regarding the ending of Kate Chopin’s novel “The Awakening” he discusses his
disappointments in the final scenes of the otherwise well-written story.
Spangler contemplates why Chopin decided to resolve the story with such a weak
characterization of Edna, when she was previously portrayed as much stronger
character. Spangler felt as though “having overcome so much in the way of
frustration, Edna is destroyed by so little.” Just letter from Robert was
enough to make her return to her originally weaker state. Spangler holds
serious doubt in the ending and feels it was held back by Chopin to protect
herself from society’s conservative views rather than peruse her own personal
vision for the ending.
I completely agree with Spangler’s
interpretation of the ending of “The Awakening”. I was disappointed to find
such a simple and easy ending for such a revolutionary and complex book. To me
it feels as though Chopin took the easy way out, using the suicide as an excuse
rather than continue to challenge the notions set by society at the time. I was
particularly disappointed in how Edna reverted back to being so weak and
dependent on men. Throughout the story I was awaiting an exciting ending where
she finally experiences liberation. I feel as though the ending didn’t comply
with the rest of the novel, as did Spangler when he said “What happened was
that Ms. Chopin provided a conclusion for a novel other than the one she wrote,
a conclusion for a novel much more conventional and much less interesting than
the Awakening.” I deeply regret not reading an ending involving Edna’s
liberation and ultimate independence regardless of societal expectations.
"The Awakening" Chapters 31-39 Dialectical Journals
|
Quote
|
Analysis
|
|
“’I thought you were going away,” she said, in an uneven
voice” (Chopin 125).
|
In this passage, Edna and Alcee go to the “chicken house”
where Edna is sleeping after the dinner party. She says that she is tired,
yet Alcee refuses to leave her when she wants him to go. This demonstrates
not on the sexual oppression Edna faced as a woman of her time, but also the
emotional oppression. She is not allowed the option of when to go to bed- a
man can decide that for her. Chopin includes this to show that although Edna
is becoming more independent, she still is unable to stand up for herself
entirely; due to the lack of respect women were allotted at the time.
|
|
“It was with a wrench and a pang that Edna left her
children. She carried away with her the sound of their voices and the touch
of their cheeks. All along the journey homeward their presence lingered with
her like the memory of a delicious song” (Chopin 128).
|
In this quotation, Chopin writes about Edna’s feelings
towards her children. Although her husband, the children’s grandmother, and
society don’t see her fit to be a mother, Edna still loves her children
unconditionally. Chopin’s purpose in including this chapter is to show that
other’s opinions don’t matter and should not influence relationships between
loved ones. She also wants to contrast how Edna feels when she is with her
children, as opposed to how she feels when she is alone. Therefore the
loneliness Edna feels is partially due to the fact that her family is taken
away from her.
|
|
“She was asked to go to early, to dinner, and Mr. Merriman
or Mr. Arobin would take her home” (Chopin 131). `
|
This passage shows how little freedom women actually had
at the time in New Orleans. Although Edna has been liberated from her family
and husband, and is living in her own new home, she still lacks the independence
to be a fully self-sufficient human. She is invited to go out with her
friends, but it is expected that a man accompany her home. This demonstrates
societal views on women at the time, and how they were considered too weak or
too unintelligent to gain enough independence to be self-reliant.
|
Wednesday, October 22, 2014
"The Awakening" Chapters 21-30 Dialectical Journals
Quote
|
Analysis
|
“Courageous, ma foi! The brave soul. The soul that
dares and defies” (Chopin 86).
|
This quotation
is exploring the new woman that Edna is becoming. She no longer feels it is
necessary to be polite and do what others want, she is now to-the-point and
blunt about what she wants. For example, when she goes to visit Mademoiselle
Reisz, she demands to read the letter from Robert. Edna is becoming more
independent and bold. Mademoiselle Reisz calls her defiant because Edna is
becoming an artist and spends her time painting. This differs from the
typical Creole woman, because their job is to be a housewife, rather than
focus on their own individual interests and hobbies. The interaction shows
just how independent and courageous Edna is becoming because Mademoiselle is
the most independent woman in the book, so Chopin wants the reader to
understand how difficult it was for women to stray from the role society has
set for them, and shows that Edna was able to do that.
|
“What should I
do if he stayed home? We wouldn’t have anything to say to each other” (Chopin
93).
|
This quote
offers deeper insight into Edna’s marriage to Leonce. When Adele says she
thinks their marriage would be better if Leonce wasn’t always going to the
club, Edna replies that she’s glad he does because they would have nothing to
talk about if he stayed home at night. Chopin uses this conversation as a
clear red flag about their marriage, and is foreshadowing to the reader that
Edna will continue to be unhappy with her husband. Chopin is telling the
reader that many women in Creole society are involved in marriages with men
they do not like, and therefore is teaching the reader that women should be
capable of choosing who they marry for the right reasons in order to be the
happiest.
|
“He was ready
at all times to submit to her moods, which were as often kind as they were
cold” (Chopin 105).
|
This quotation
depicts Edna’s complicated friendship with Alcee Arobin. Alcee is similar to
Robert in the sense that Edna feels closer to them than she does to her
husband. Chopin is hinting that Edna has severe moodswings, and the reader
can infer that she is mentally ill. Alcee provides a foil to Leonce because he
is patient with Edna despite her mood. Leonce went to the doctors to
determine what was wrong with Edna, while Alcee just accepts Edna’s complex
characteristics. This contrast shows how Chopin feels it is important to
marry someone who understands you and will accept you on both bad and good
days.
|
Tuesday, October 21, 2014
"The Awakening" Chapters 11-20 Dialectical Journals
|
Quote
|
Analysis
|
|
“She heard him
moving around the room; every sound indicating impatience and irritation.
Another time she would have gone in at his request. She would, through habit,
have yielded to his desire; not with any sense of submission or obedience to
his compelling wishes, but unthinkingly, as we walk, move, sit, stand, go
through the daily treadmill of the life which has been portioned out to us”
(Chopin 42).
|
In this
passage, Edna is showing her first actions of resistance towards her husband.
She refuses to obey him and go inside. This demonstrates her continued
self-growth after her interaction with the ocean, which symbolizes her
independence. Chopin uses the metaphor of the daily treadmill of life to
represent how Edna’s days are all the same. She always obeys her husband
without questioning or thinking about it, even if she does not want to.
Therefore, Chopin is showing the growth that Edna is experiencing through her
slight rebellion towards her husband. This applies to the author’s purpose by
showing how women do not need to comply with society’s standards.
|
|
“Edna said it
was good. She had not though of coffee or anything” (Chopin 44).
|
This quotation
holds a great deal of symbolism. The short and simple sentences symbolize how
Edna lacked thoughtfulness prior to now. The fact that she didn’t have any
opinions of coffee, which is a simple, everyday drink, shows how little
control she had over her own thoughts and opinions. Because she is a woman,
she is not expected to have her own opinions about things, and she has always
followed this social law, lacking deep thought about anything. Chopin also
includes this quote to show how Edna’s relationship with Robert differs from
her relationship with her husband. Chopin creates a huge contrast between
chapter 11’s depiction of Mr. Pontellier smoking cigars and telling Edna to
go to bed, and chapter 12’s depiction of Robert encouraging Edna to have her
own thoughts and opinions. Chopin wants the female readers to understand that
they are entitled to their own thoughts and opinions and should surround
themselves with those who think similarly.
|
|
“Edna took him
in her arms, and seating herself in the rocker began to coddle and caress
him, calling him all manner of tender names, soothing him to sleep” (Chopin
53).
|
This passage
is crucial to the characterization of Edna. Although her husband, and people
of the town perceive her to be a bad mother, and she appears to resent her
motherhood, she still cares about her children. Chopin is telling the reader
that it is acceptable for women to yearn for independence from their
husbands, and their societal role as mothers, yet still love their children.
Chopin is trying to portray the message that mother’s can still love their
children regardless of their happiness in their role as a housewife.
|
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)